How to compare supplier quotes when names and pack sizes differ

A higher case price can be the cheaper buy. Compare per unit, or per kilo, never per case.

· 4 min read

Supplier A offers tea at €36.00 a case, supplier B at €39.60. A looks cheaper — but A's case is 12 × 500 g and B's is 24 × 250 g. Comparing case prices compares two different things.

Bring both to the same unit

Supplier ASupplier B
Pack12 × 500 g24 × 250 g
Case price€36.00€39.60
Unit cost€3.00€1.65
Per kilo€6.00€6.60

Per unit, B looks cheaper (€1.65 against €3.00) — but B's unit is half the size. Per kilo, A is 10% cheaper. When sizes differ, compare per kilo or per litre; when they are the same, per unit. Working out the unit is covered in case price vs unit cost.

Different packs, one comparison: price per kilo.

Match the product, not the words

Suppliers name the same product differently, so match by brand, product and size before you compare. Then add what changes the real cost: transport, minimum order and payment terms — see adding transport to product costs.

How SAMZY does it

Every invoice or price list you bring in becomes a Smart Sheet with the supplier's name. Compare quotations in SAMZY Intelligence puts two suppliers' sheets side by side and shows, product by product, who is cheaper. Click a product in any sheet to see every supplier's price for it, and how it has changed over time — see tracking supplier price changes.

Questions

How do I compare quotes with different pack sizes?
Convert each to the same base: unit cost when units are the same size, price per kilo or litre when they differ.
Is the cheapest case price the best deal?
Not always. A cheaper case can hold fewer or smaller units, so its price per kilo can be higher.